Costco’s development in Redmond to impact Kirkland sales tax receipts

Since it first opened in 1985, Kirkland’s flagship Costco Warehouse has been a major source of sales tax revenue for the City of Kirkland, drawing shoppers in from neighboring cities as well as from Kirkland itself. For much of this time, the Kirkland Costco store has enjoyed the competitive advantage of having little direct competition from other Costco or other competing stores such as Sam’s Club. When plans were announced in 2007 for Costco to build new stores in Redmond and Bellevue, this was a cause for concern to the City of Kirkland, as it was estimated that the addition of these two new Costco warehouses could reduce the sales of the Kirkland warehouse significantly.
In Bellevue, Costco made plans to demolish the long vacant former Kmart store on 148th and build a new warehouse in its place. The City of Bellevue mandated that this project require Kelsey Creek (which currently runs through a culvert under the parking lot) be daylighted and rehabilitated — an expensive undertaking. Ultimately, the cost of this required stream rehabilitation would prove too much for Costco, and in November 2008, Costco announced that they were abandoning the idea of building a store on that particular site.
Meanwhile, plans for a store in Redmond were also announced in July of 2007 with an expected opening date of Fall 2008, but until recently there has not been much activity at the site. Land use applications for the new Costco warehouse were filed with the City of Redmond in November 2008.
In total, three different land use applications have been filed with the City related to the Costco store. One of these deals with the subdivision of 60 acres of property formerly used as part of the Cadman rock quarry into eight different lots of various sizes and the construction of necessary roads, with the largest being the lot for the Costco store at 15.6 acres. The other two applications are for permits to build the store itself, and to build the 16-pump Costco gas station which will accompany the store. The store itself will apparently be similar in layout to the Woodinville Costco store that opened a couple of years ago, and will include 644 parking spaces (compared to 716 spaces currently available at the Kirkland Costco, reduced to 682 after the proposed gas station at that location is constructed).
Based on the information in the land use applications, we can get a better idea of the location as well. The new Costco store will be located at the corner of NE 76th Street and 188th Ave. NE, an intersection which does not exist currently. Right now, 188th consists of one short segment north of Union Hill Road next to the Millennium campus, and one that goes from 202 up to NE 68th, passing through a residential neighborhood and next a portion of the Genie Industries complex that takes up much of this area. Under the proposal, 188th Ave. NE would be extended from NE 68th to Union Hill Road, creating another link between Union Hill Road and Highway 202. NE 76th (which passes between the Target and Fred Meyer stores about a half mile west of the proposed Costco) would also be slightly extended to intersect with the new segment of 188th.
This satellite image shows the expected site of the Costco (in green with a blue border), the space for the other subdivided lots in the area (in gray with the green border) and the extensions of 188th Ave. NE and NE 76th St. that will be built to service this new development in red. Aside from the fact that these lots will be zoned for light industrial use, it is unclear what exactly what will be constructed here at this time.
I made an inquiry to Asma Jeelani, the City of Redmond project planner in charge of these land use applications, and I found out that the application for the Costco store itself has now been approved, and that construction of the roads and infrastructure for the new Costco is expected to begin by April 1st. In the meantime, the gas station has not yet been approved, and a public hearing for that part of the project has been scheduled for February 9th. I suspect that adding a gas station to a Costco being built in a former gravel pit will probably be somewhat less controversial than one being built right next to a residential neighborhood.
While the construction of a new Costco will greatly benefit their members living in Redmond and the outlying communities in the Snoqualmie Valley, the effect this will have on the Kirkland store (and the tax revenues that it generates for the city) remains to be seen. When the new Redmond and Bellevuestores were proposed in 2007, it was estimated that these stores could reduce sales at the Kirkland Costco by as much as a third. With the cancellation of the Bellevue store, the effect was expected to be reduced significantly, but currently there is no estimate of how much the new Redmond store will affect sales in the Kirkland store. For many residents of Redmond, the Kirkland store will still be closer than its Redmond counterpart, which will be located well outside the downtown core of Redmond, but should be relatively accessible via 520, 202 and Union Hill Road. The addition of gasoline to the Kirkland Costco location is intended to mitigate the reduction of sales caused by the opening of the new Costco store in Redmond (and presumably the Woodinville store as well, although it is uncertain how much that store has affected sales at the Kirkland location). In spite of the city’s approval of the Private Amendment Request to allow gasoline on the Kirkland Costco property, it appears that this may be tied up in appeals for some time to come. In the meantime, it appears that Redmondians won’t have to wait too much longer for cheap hot dogs and HDTVs in their backyard.
Brian Lutz, author of this article, is a resident of Redmond and is author of The Sledghammer – Version 2.0 blog.
Related Stories:
|
|
|
|
|














Good analysis! This Redmond location is far inferior. Compare it with their Kirkland store, just off I-405 and 85th NE, with such heavy volumns of north-south, east-west traffic flows. It doesn’t take a “rocket-surgeon” to know where to do your Costco shopping.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
I do have to agree that the location is a bit out-of-the-way (and will in fact be some distance away from any other significant retail but at the same time, it also means that there should (hopefully) be less traffic headaches involved with getting there and back. The Kirkland location is relatively easy to get into, but at times (especially at rush hour) it can be a serious pain to make a left turn onto 85th the place onto 85th from 120th or 124th to get out of the place. Usually you will spend several minutes waiting for the green arrow, then half the time it seems like you end up flooring it through the yellow because it takes several minutes of extra waiting if you end up stuck there for another cycle. And with the onramp to 405 there, 85th in that area is busy all the time. Then there’s the fact that most of the time when I go to the Kirkland Costco the parking lot is full to the point where you end up parking some distance away from the store (the distance between the farthest parking spot out in Costco’s back lot is almost a quarter of a mile from the entrance of the store. That’s a worst case scenario, but the farthest spot from the entrance in the main lot is still 275 yards out, and I frequently end up parking in that section (for lack of other spots) unless I go about an hour before closing on a week day.
It is entirely possible that a new Costco in this area will help alleviate this situation somewhat, but at what cost to the City’s coffers remains to be seen. I think it was Yogi Berra who said of a popular restaurant in New York City that “Nobody goes there anymore, it’s too crowded.”
Like or Dislike:
0
1
I am not quite sure why you feel the Kirkland location is “superior” to the location in Redmond. My wife and I are already frequently on that side of Redmond to go to Target, Whole Foods, Fred Meyer, and Home Depot–and we live on the west side of Redmond. It is considerably more convenient for us to get over to the new Costco location than it is for the many residents up in Sammamish to get to the Kirkland location. The big problem, for me at least, with the Kirkland store is not the location, it is the parking and the lines. No automated check-out lines, not enough parking, a space reserved for “employee of the month” (nice gesture, but you are already limited in spaces for /paying customers/), and the traffic. When my wife and I need to go to Costco, we almost always go up to Woodinville even though it is 3x the distance. It is just so much less frustrating.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
My guess is that there is pent up demand from those of us who DON’T go as often to the Kirkland location because its so darn crazy all the time. My guess is there will be an initial drop in sales but not as significant as predicted and then it will rise back to normal as people like me increase their visits, increasing even more once the gas station opens.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
So Michelle, as the Chamber of Commerce lady, what route will you take to the new Kirkland Costco gas station? Wind you way through their crowded parking lot, get in the long line up 90th past the Presbyterian church or sneak in the back SW side of the warehouse?
Like or Dislike:
0
0
look at this as a developer would. here we have two neighboring towns of redmond and kirkland that are very different. one is welcoming to development. the other is full of conflict, appeals and lawsuits. it is sad to see the contrast. the utopia we are preserving in kirkland is not a happy place to be. the only people who can be happy with things are the angry people stopping every move for progress.
is kirkland’s gas station held up? how long until there is a groundbreaking? i want the lower priced gas.
Like or Dislike:
0
0
As a former Kirkland resident and current resident of Duvall (yes, there is life outside of Kirkland and it’s good, I promise!) I am looking forward to this new Costco. I hate going to the Kirkland Costco, it’s a mess, parking is horrible, it’s crowded, and the customers are rude. We tend to do all of our Costco shopping at the Woodinville Costco for right now, it’s newer and nicer. Heck I’ll go to the 4th AVE store in Downtown Seattle before venturing into the Kirkland store. Try driving past the end of 520 sometime, there’s a whole new world out here you’ve never seen before!
Like or Dislike:
0
0
So true GiGi….shopping at Kirkland Costco is nasty all right. Can you imagine how impossible it will be with the gas station? The low gas prices are welcome, but they must provide more parking. I think they assume all of us just get gas and then leave. Wrong! These economic times demands that we kill more than one bird with a single stone. Go shopping and gas-up at the same time, now that makes sense. Get the hint Costco?
Like or Dislike:
0
0